What is “Evidence-Based Resistance Training”?

Over at the company blog, I wrote a post defining Evidence-Based Resistance Training. This phrase, while useful, implies a flowchart or an immutable set of rules for what the research base has determined to be productive. It isn’t and it doesn’t. Here’s my expansion below.


In exercise, you might assume that trainers follow best practices, informed by what the peer-reviewed research confirms is safe and effective for trainees over a wide age range.

You’d be wrong.

Evidence-Based Resistance Training, Explained

Most of what passes for exercise in commercial gyms is ineffective at best and dangerous at worst. At Smart Strength we practice “Evidence-Based Resistance Training,” but what does that mean?

Let me explain with the help of this handy diagram:

Smart Strength Evidence Based Resistance Training Venn

Let’s break this down shall we?

1. What the research says works

When it comes to resistance training, most things don’t work very well, are dangerous, and have limited ecological validity. So we look for what the literature says works for most people, safely, across their training career. In other words, X works under Y conditions given Z constraints.

This however is merely a menu, not a map. If the literature was extremely precise, you wouldn’t need an experienced, educated trainer to help make sense of the variables; you’d only need a flowchart.

Which leads us to…

2. Trainer Experience

When it comes to applying training principles that have been proven to work, there’s no one better than an experienced, educated trainer to help you. At Smart Strength, we marry university education with a robust continuing education and certification process. This means that our trainers are actual professionals, ready to help clients marry what the research says works for their goals with their affect and circumstances.

3. Client Preference 

We’re the experts, but in order to do our job to the best of our ability, client preference is taken into account. If a client does not like the A+, most-effective exercise or method for whatever reason, then a B+ solution is great because long-term adherence is required to make and maintain all of the look great, feel great, perform great benefits of resistance training.

Putting it all together

At Smart Strength, our expert trainers use their experience to prescribe the safest, most effective exercises and methods to where the client is at to help them look better, feel better, and become the strongest version of themselves. This sets us apart in the crowded fitness landscape!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s